Coyles Homemade Ice Cream in Islip

Great

Best ice cream on Long Island!

Lots of varieties of fresh delicious flavors

Excellent Icecream and Service

Delish icecream, great place for kids to gather. Memories are everything 💞

They're ice is always delicious!! They have great varieties and they're made right there at their store. We love the creaminess of their ice cream, can't get tire of this place.

It's good kewl people behind counter.

Love all the flavors

Love all their flavors!

I still think it's an American thing to do to go out with your kids and get some ice cream I like this place and it's right on main giving it that small town feel

Delicious creamy ice cream, many flavor options to choose from, many toppings to choose from, how many times a challenge to find parking. If you can find a parking space even if you have to walk several blocks it's probably going to be worth it if you stopped in.

Yummy

Fantastic quality ice cream. Haven't had anything else on the island that beats the quality of this homemade ice cream. The service was also fantastic. The girl behind the counter was very accommodating and helpful. This became an instant favorite for me.

So friendly! Delicious frozen treats!

Delicious homemade icecream. They were extremely friendly. The variety of flavors was insane.

The icecream and customer service is always great

I was very surprised at how small this place is. There is free parking around back, but we had trouble finding a space as it was very busy on a Monday evening. They have a large menu board listing the wide variety of supposedly handmade ice cream flavors and sunday's. I canNOT believe they do NOT offer one frozen yogurt OR EVEN one low fat option! We waited in line behind 6 other people and were served promptly. There is also seating out back facing the parking lot. My choice was pecan which had chunks of nuts in it. It was creamy but very, very sugary. My husband got plain vanilla and said the same thing. Two small cones cost about $13.00 !!!

Too expensive and smaller sizes then most.

I don't know!! I being there 2x try different ice cream and I don't taste the flavors, maybe is just me🤔

Delicious and unique

Line out the door type of homemade ice cream! Always great ice cream sodas and service!

Best ice cream on Long Island!!

Delicious, freshly made ice cream - overly priced, sadly.

Ice cream is excellent!

Ice cream is amazing we love this place sometimes it gets really crowded and there might be only one or 2 people behind the counter and feel bad ...otherwise their icecream is amazing!

The ice cream is Great, lots of flavors and home made taste. Mom and pop type of business. Not a lot of seating space. It could use some redecorating. It closes too early in my opinion.

I really love their ice cream. At first I thought I won't liked it that much but I was so wrong. The staff are super friendly, making customers feel welcomed with very nice local home atmosphere.

Awesome Ice Cream. It makes you happy to be alive.

Just finished the most expensive ice cream. The portions are so small for the money you pay. Staff was not friendly, the milkshake had the consistency of chocolate milk. I will never go there again. To top it off two grown men started shouting profanities at eachother in front of all the kids. Way to keep it classy!

Coyles is all local made ice cream and is fantastic.

Delicious ice cream, the cannoli flavored ice cream actually had cannolis in it!!

I was so excited to finally try some locally made ice cream but theirs was sickeningly sweet! We tried three different flavors and all were syrupy and too gross too eat. It would be great if they could try making some new batches with less sugar and more flavor.

Best ice cream Shoppe on Long Island

Amazing ice cream. Very nice staff

The ice cream is the best and the service is great.

👍🏽

It’s super tasty, you can tell the ice cream is homemade. They have a ton of flavors. It’s pretty overpriced though.

Great homemade Ice cream

I go here because it's in town and it's so close to my house. I just went there at 9:25 and they were closed. Hours say open until 9:30 which is still a joke. The girl looked at me and continued to ignore me. I pointed to my watch showing her the time but she didn't care. So never again for this place. That was straight rude.

We just went for the first time. The ice cream was excellent!

Very delicious

Great local spot!

Great ice cream

Lots of flavors and yummy! Not too sure about the "homemade" part since they do use quotes around homemade.

A mom & pop look, GREAT ice cream. Good variety of flavors. Recommend.

It was just okay for me. I use to go to Coyles as a child and I guess it just seemed so much better back then. I will try again it again and re-review sometime soon.

Great homemade ice cream

Great ice cream with creative flavors

Awesome ice cream, wide variety of flavors and toppings, excellent service.

the ice cream here is amazing, there are so many flavors. also the parlor is super cute!